In Search of the Best Bakery Pie in Santa Rosa and Sonoma County

This November I scoured Sonoma County to find the best holiday pie (for the sake of good blog content of course) I decided to compare pumpkin pies in particular so I could compare apples to apples or in this case pumpkins to pumpkins. I have never really been a big lover of pumpkin pie but this endeavor has changed my heart. A store bought or mass produced frozen pie can not compare to these wonderful bakery pies. The four bakeries I liked the most were from a larger sampling of restaurants and bakeries throughout the county - each that make their own pies.
My favorite bakery overall was “Costeaux French Bakery” in Healdsburg. I was pleased with the packaging for the to-go pieces of pie I ordered and they were perfectly happy to slice into whole pies from the case to let me have just one piece (I tested this willingness on a piece of blackberry pie also) I liked the texture and flavor of the filling although the crust could have been more special. The best things about this bakery that the others were lacking was a nice eating area and a great location in relevance to doing other things in the same outing. The inside of the bakery, recently remodeled, has lots of places to sit including the little outside patio area that feels a bit European without being thematic. After eating a delicious sandwich at Costeaux French Bakery, I took my pie to the nearby park square in the city’s center. It was a great way to enjoy a pleasant fall day.

I discovered a little pie shop close by in Santa Rosa that is on our list of favorites. “Betty’s Fish and Chips” is in an “on the way to somewhere else” kind of location so it can be easily missed. Don’t let the fish and chips part of Betty’s scare you away from trying the pie shop that resides next door to the fish and chips restaurant. The auxiliary bakery shop was added because the word-of-mouth about Betty’s pies created the need. They are well-known for their mini fruit pies that have the most heavenly crust and are perfectly sized for our picnic lunches we take to the nearby Spring Lake at Howarth Park. The pumpkin pie we sampled had a really nice crust and very good texture. In comparison to some of the other pies I thought it was just a little bit bland but my partner in pie sampling duties thought it was very good.
If you are looking for the prettiest pumpkin pie to impress your guests I would recommend “Michelle Marie’s Patisserie” within Montgomery Village in Santa Rosa. Michelle Marie’s Patisserie is a bakery and cafe with some really yummy bakery goods and consistently good lunch foods. Their pumpkin pie had the very best crust and an excellent texture and appearance but not as flavorful as Costeaux or Mom’s.

“Mom’s Apple Pie” in Sebastopol is a bit away from Santa Rosa (about 20 minutes) but it is fully worth the drive to experience their pumpkin pie. Our pie was served up just out of the oven; it still had little swirls of steam coming from it as we sat down in the patio area to eat it. I don’t think I will taste a better pumpkin pie - ever. Thinking maybe Mom’s had an unfair advantage because it was warm out of the oven and it had the swirling steam thing going on - we went back to give it another taste. This time we bought a whole pie and we ate it chilled; it was still the best pumpkin pie ever.
I think you will be pleased with the pumpkin pies from all of these bakeries. Try all of them while pumpkin pie is still in season. For our holiday dinner we ended up ordering a pumpkin and an apricot pie from Costeaux French Bakery in Healdsburg. We wanted an excuse to have lunch there again and walk around the little nearby park before fall slipped away.















